Ruben Amaro Jr. has no intention of giving up on this season or the next several seasons. He said as much—link. Privately he knows the situation is bleak for 2012, but given the age and guaranteed contracts on their roster, how can they conceivably let Cole Hamels leave as a free agent without a viable offer? It’s getting close to the point where the Phillies have to realize that this simply isn’t their year. They’re not there yet, but it’s a few weeks away—conveniently coinciding with the July 31st trading deadline.
After what happened with Cliff Lee having been traded away and then choosing to re-sign with the club a year later, it’s conceivable that the Phillies would check with Hamels to see if he’d be willing to be traded to a contender for the remainder of 2012 so they could re-stock the system and then go after him as a free agent.
Let’s look at the contracts, the guaranteed money owed for 2013 and beyond and the viability of re-signing Hamels.
Lee is owed $87.5 million through 2016.
Roy Halladay will be paid $20 million in 2013 and has a club option for $20 million at 2014.
Ryan Howard is signed for $95 through 2016.
Chase Utley is owed $15 million next season.
Jonathan Papelbon is owed $13 million annually through 2015 with a vesting option at $13 million for 2016.
Jimmy Rollins is guaranteed $22 million through 2014.
Hunter Pence is a free agent after 2013.
All-Star catcher Carlos Ruiz has a ridiculously cheap $5 million option for 2013 that, barring catastrophe, will be exercised.
Kyle Kendrick is signed for $4 million next season, but they can find a taker for him.
The Phillies’ current payroll is $172 million.
Lee’s getting a $3.5 million raise next year; Papelbon slightly less than $2 million. Pence will get a raise in arbitration of $4-5 million. They’re slashing between $28 and $36 million (give or take) after Victorino, Blanton, Polanco, Ty Wigginton, Jose Contreras and Kendrick are gone.
Their payroll is going down, so technically this talk that they can’t “possibly” keep Hamels is inaccurate. They can afford to keep Hamels.
The question is will they do it during the season? Will they trade him and hope to re-sign him? Will they trade him and just let him sign wherever? Or will they keep him and take their chances retaining him in free agency?
If what Amaro said is true in terms of keeping the team together until they disintegrate, the Phillies don’t have much of a choice: they have to have Hamels in a Phillies’ uniform.